Trump’s Coal Plant Extensions Face Questions Over Cost, Reliability and Federal Authority
The Trump administration has been using emergency orders and federal financing to keep coal plants running over the last year, to keep various facilities that were due to be decommissioned in operation. This reflects President Trump’s broader support for expanding the U.S. fossil fuel industry as part of his energy agenda.
The decision to continue supporting coal operations has led to backlash from environmental groups and renewable energy supporters. In addition, some states and operators have launched legal action over concerns around effective energy production and the cost of keeping plants online.
Trump Administration on Coal
Upon coming into office in January 2025, President Trump declared a National Energy Emergency. Trump vowed to reverse “the war on American coal by stopping the premature shutdown of coal-fired power plants, and expanding coal infrastructure to improve grid reliability, lower energy costs, and support American coal workers.”
In February this year, Trump welcomed lawmakers, industry leaders, and miners from across the country to the White House “Champion of Coal” event, where he signed an Executive Order directing the Department of War to purchase coal power, celebrated the Tennessee Valley Authority’s recommitment to coal, and was honored by coal miners as the “Undisputed Champion of Beautiful, Clean Coal”. In the event, Trump stressed his unwavering support for coal.
Then, in June, the U.S. Department of Energy (DoE) reaffirmed its commitment to America’s coal mining industry by announcing its intent to save or support an additional 17 coal plants and one export facility. This brought the total number of coal plants supported or “saved” by the DoE to 45, representing 40 gigawatts (GW) of power.
The DoE stated, “As a result of the Trump Administration’s actions, at least 42 coal mines will likely remain in operation.” It also estimated that roughly $50 billion in costs for building new power generation have been saved and that DoE investments will generate approximately an additional $1.7 billion in private-sector investment to revitalize the coal industry.
The Colorado Case
The U.S. Secretary of Energy, Chris Wright, issued an emergency order in June to keep a Colorado coal plant operational just one day before it was slated for closure. The order directed Tri-State Generation and Transmission Association (Tri-State), Platte River Power Authority, Salt River Project, PacifiCorp, and Public Service Company of Colorado (a subsidiary of Xcel Energy) to take all measures necessary to ensure that Craig Unit 1 is available to operate at the direction of the Southwest Power Pool (SPP).
At the time, Wright said, “Taking reliable generation off the grid compromises energy reliability and needlessly raises energy costs for Americans… During peak summer demand, Coloradans deserve continued access to affordable, reliable, and secure energy to power and cool their homes.”
In 2016, the operator decided that closing Craig 1 was the most cost-effective option for its customers and to meet air quality requirements. However, in response, Xcel Energy has spent over $4 million to keep the Craig Unit 1 coal plant online, despite still calling for plans to close the plant to be followed through on.
The plant reportedly produced little electricity between January and June 2026, as it stood idle, except in April, according to federal Energy Information Administration records.
Federal Court Rejects Trump’s Bid to Keep Michigan Coal Plant Running
While some operators are following federal orders to keep coal plants running, some projects have been blocked in recent months. In September, a federal court ruled that the DoE had exceeded its authority in using emergency power to force operators to keep a coal-fired power plant in Michigan open past its scheduled retirement date last year.
The decision was the result of a court case brought by environmental groups and three states – Michigan, Illinois, and Minnesota – to allow for the decommissioning of the 64-year-old JH Campbell Generating plant. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit agreed with the plaintiffs that there was no real emergency under the law.
Appeals court judge Cornelia Pillard wrote for a unanimous three-judge panel, saying that the Federal Power Act, which allows emergency orders, “is essentially a narrow, last-resort backstop”. Pillard added that by reversing the Campbell plant’s “long and carefully planned retirement … the results are disruptive.” In addition, there was “no ‘emergency’ within the meaning” of the statute, the judge said.
The Michigan case is just one of several legal disputes that have arisen after the Trump administration decided to use emergency powers to force several coal-fired plants online.
Contrary to what the Trump administration has suggested, studies have shown that continuing to operate some coal plants, in states such as Indiana, Colorado, Florida, and Washington, is increasing ratepayer bills and adding air and water pollution that could have been avoided.
Keeping the Michigan plant open beyond its May 2025 retirement has cost around $259 million to date, according to new financial filings, which many critics of the plan believe ratepayers will be expected to pay.
The Michigan case has the potential to set a precedent for courts ruling on other coal plant extensions to overrule the Trump administration’s emergency action, particularly if supported by states and operators associated with the plant. Moving forward, further study of the plant extensions carried out over the past year could better inform future energy policy.
Keep In Touch with Shale Magazine
As the new era of energy unfolds, you can bet we’ll be the boots on the ground to keep you informed. Subscribe to Shale Magazine for sharp insight into the arenas that matter most to your life. And don’t forget to listen to our riveting podcast, The Energy Mixx Radio Show, where our very own Kym Bolado interviews the most extraordinary thought leaders, business innovators, and industry experts of our time.



